Shubman Gill is often seen as one of India’s brightest young cricket stars, but some people believe he may be overrated.
While he has shown great talent, there are several reasons why critics think he doesn’t deserve all the praise he gets.
Here are three reasons why some believe Shubman Gill does not live up to the hype surrounding him.
1. Inconsistent First-Innings Performance
One of the main criticisms of Shubman Gill is his inconsistency in first innings across formats. While he has shown brilliance in second-innings situations, his first-innings average in Test cricket is notably low.
For instance, his overall average in first innings stands at just 28.6, which is significantly lower than his second-innings average of 51.0.
This stark contrast raises concerns about his ability to perform when it matters most, particularly in crucial matches where setting a strong foundation is essential.
2. Limited Impact in T20s and ODIs
While Gill has made headlines with his performances, particularly in the IPL, his overall impact in T20s and ODIs has been mixed.
His T20 average of 29.94 and ODI average of 58.27 may seem decent, but they do not reflect the consistency expected from a player touted as a future star.
Critics argue that while he has had standout innings, such as a double century in ODIs, these performances are not frequent enough to justify the high praise he receives.
3. Overhyped Comparisons to Legends
Shubman Gill is often compared to established legends like Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma, which can lead to inflated expectations.
While comparisons can be motivating, they can also create unrealistic standards for young players.
Critics argue that Gill’s performances should be viewed independently rather than through the lens of past greats.
This pressure may affect his game and lead to inconsistent performances as he tries to live up to these comparisons.
