Prithvi Shaw’s recent performance in the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy has drawn significant criticism, especially following a disappointing showing in the tournament final.
The young Mumbai opener, who has been under scrutiny for his fitness and form, managed to score only 10 runs off 6 balls in the crucial match against Madhya Pradesh, contributing little to Mumbai’s successful chase of 175 runs.
This lackluster performance has reignited discussions about his struggles and the factors affecting his game.
Disappointing Final Performance
In the final held at the M Chinnaswamy Stadium, Shaw’s early dismissal was a stark reminder of his ongoing issues.
Despite being a key player for Mumbai, he failed to capitalize on the opportunity when it mattered most.
His dismissal left Mumbai at a precarious position of 50 for 2 during the powerplay.
Although the team ultimately secured victory, thanks to strong performances from Suryakumar Yadav and Suryansh Shedge, Shaw’s inability to contribute significantly raised eyebrows among fans and analysts alike.
Criticism Of Fitness and Form
Shaw’s fitness has been a recurring theme in discussions about his career trajectory. Former cricketer Pravin Amre, who previously worked with Shaw at Delhi Capitals, publicly criticized him for not putting in enough effort in training and gym sessions.
Amre labeled Shaw “his own enemy,” emphasizing that without dedication to improving his fitness, no one could assist him in reviving his career.
This sentiment resonates with many fans who have noted that Shaw’s physical condition appears to be impacting his performance on the field.
Recent Struggles and IPL Auction Snub
The Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy has been a mixed bag for Shaw. While he did have a standout innings of 49 runs against Vidarbha in the quarterfinals, he ended the tournament with only 197 runs across nine matches and no half-centuries.
His inconsistency has been further highlighted by two ducks in five innings during the tournament.
Adding to his woes, Shaw went unsold during the IPL 2025 auction despite being listed with a base price of ₹75 lakh. This absence from the IPL has intensified scrutiny regarding his future in professional cricket.
Looking Ahead
As Shaw reflects on his performance in the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy, he faces an uphill battle to regain form and confidence.
With the Vijay Hazare Trophy on the horizon, he will need to focus on improving both his fitness and batting consistency to secure his place in Mumbai’s lineup and potentially earn another shot at IPL selection.
His childhood coach, Jwala Singh, expressed sadness over Shaw’s decline, urging him to concentrate on honing his skills and returning to the form that once made him a promising talent in Indian cricket.
